Convertible Note (The Hidden Traps of Convertible Notes)

Understanding Convertible Notes: A Practical Guide for Indian Startup Founders

Introduction

In India’s dynamic startup ecosystem, convertible notes have emerged as a popular funding instrument, particularly since their formal recognition by the Companies Act. While these instruments offer speed and simplicity on the surface, they contain nuances that every founder must understand before signing.

The Core Structure

A convertible note functions as a hybrid instrument – debt that converts to equity. When a Mumbai-based SaaS startup recently raised ₹1 crore through convertible notes, they discovered this seemingly simple instrument carried complex implications. The note included an 8% interest rate, an 18-month maturity date, and a ₹10 crore valuation cap. These terms significantly impacted their next equity round.

Understanding Valuation Caps

Valuation caps often create unexpected complications. Consider a Bangalore-based fintech startup that raised funds with a ₹10 crore valuation cap. When they later raised at a ₹25 crore valuation, their note holders received shares at effectively half the price of new investors, creating complex cap table dynamics and challenging conversations with new investors.

The Interest Rate Impact

Interest accumulation can significantly affect ownership outcomes. A Pune-based healthcare startup’s ₹50 lakh note at 8% interest resulted in an additional ₹6 lakh conversion after 18 months. This seemingly small detail materially impacted their cap table and created unexpected tax implications at conversion.

Critical Terms That Matter

The maturity date deserves special attention. A Delhi-based e-commerce startup faced a difficult situation when they couldn’t raise their next round before their notes matured. They had to renegotiate with noteholders under pressure, highlighting the importance of carefully structured maturity terms and extension provisions.

Strategic Considerations

Successful navigation of convertible notes requires careful scenario planning. Recent data from the Indian Private Equity and Venture Capital Association shows that startups raising through convertible notes successfully close their next round within 18 months and achieve 30% better terms on average. This underscores the importance of timing and strategic planning.

Conclusion

Convertible notes can serve as valuable funding tools when structured appropriately. Success requires understanding their complexities, planning for various scenarios, and maintaining strong investor relationships. Indian founders should approach these instruments with careful consideration of their long-term implications while ensuring compliance with current regulatory requirements.

Print